Speaking Notes CC

Back to Home Print This Page Email This Page

Notes For Cathy Carroll, Secretary Treasurer SEIU Local 1 Canada

SEIU - Local 1 Canada

The Local Health Integration Act (Bill 36) will radically alter the way Ontario's citizens will access health care services.

This Act will also drastically alter the lives of all health care workers, particularly health care workers who provide "non-clinical health care services."

SEIU Local 1.on represents mainly Registered Practical Nurses and non clinical service staff, such as dietary, housekeeping and clerical, in the health care sector.

The legislation does not clearly define "non-clinical services." Section 33(1) of Bill 36 allows for a very broad definition of "non-clinical services. It will allow the government to cease performing any prescribed non clinical service and to integrate the service by-transferring it to a prescribed person or entity.

The legislation is clear in its intent and purpose. Non-clinical health care services will be put on the auction block.

This will have a devastating impact on both health care consumers and health care workers alike.

  1. Health care workers. The average "non clinical health care worker earns less than $36,000 per year.

    Already they pay $450.00 per year in the new Health Tax. In essence they are subsidizing their own wages.

    If contracting out of non-clinical services is allowed, and clearly this legislation will allow it, workers such as dietary and housekeeping will be contracted out to for profit companies such as Aramark, Sodexho and Morrison Compass.

    The British Columbia health privatization scheme a few years ago resulted in "non clinical health care providers" having had their wages slashed nearly in half. They lost their pensions and their benefits.

    SEIU Local 1.on believes the Ontario government's intention is to balance the provincial budget on the backs of the most vulnerable health care workers. Health Minister Smitherman has described these workers as low hanging fruit.

    I want to point out that what workers do not earn they can not spend in their communities. In smaller communities, health care is the foundation of the local economy. If health care workers are forced into poverty wages, as home care workers were when their jobs were subjected to competitive bidding, local businesses too will suffer, because what health care workers do not earn they cannot spend.

  2. Health care consumers. They too pay McGuinty's new Health Tax - as much as $900 per year.

    Since being elected, this government has already delisted chiropractic services. (OHIP used to pay $11.65 for the first visit, $9.65 for additional visits to a maximum of $150.00 per year.)

    Physiotherapy services at approved provincial clinics - delisted. (OHIP previously funded up to $500 per year).

    Optometry services (eye examinations) were delisted for every one between the ages of 20 - 64.

    Will other services be delisted or will the government now use privatization to achieve its cost cutting health care strategies?

    We are witnessing the transfer of massive public tax dollars to for profit corporations both as P3 initiatives expand and health services are put up for auction.

    Bill 36 will force Ontario tax payers to pay for every service not subject to the Canada Health Act. User fees violate the very principles of the Canada Health Act. They amount to nothing more than double taxation. The lowest income groups pay a larger share. User fees are a barrier to health care access.

    Bill 36 will allow hospitals to create more for private clinics within themselves such as physiotherapy clinics.

    The development of private stand alone health clinics will accelerate the rush to a two tier health care system.

    As food services, housekeeping and clerical services are privatized, private for profit companies supplying these services to the health care sector will also be able to charge user fees. In effect health care ancillary services charged to the user will turn our public health care institutions into nothing more than hotels.

    Need a tooth brush - Pay for it
    Need clean linen - Pay for it
    Need a meal - Pay for it
    Need to drive 500 Km for treatment - Pay for it

    Health care workers and Ontario citizens alike can no longer afford or trust this government with their pubic health care dollars.

Service Employees International Union Local1.on is a 40,000 member province wide local union serving health care and community support workers.